This paper compares two primary methods for discovering Web application vulnerabilities: using manual penetration testing and code review or using automated scanning tools and static analysis.
This IBM white paper, dated January 2008 and written by Danny Allan of IBM Software Group, compares two methods for discovering Web application vulnerabilities: manual penetration testing and code review versus automated scanning tools and static analysis. It notes that many Web sites are vulnerable to attacks that travel over HTTP/S ports exposed to the whole online community, and that large amounts of personal, medical and financial data are exchanged and stored by increasingly complex Web applications.
The paper describes how manual penetration testers emerged and how automated testing tools were developed in the late 1990s, then splits vulnerabilities into technical and logical categories. It argues that automated tools are efficient for testing large numbers of technical checks, while only a human tester can understand an application's workflow and expose logical flaws. The closing section describes IBM Rational Web application security testing products and how to get more information from IBM.
They are grouped into technical vulnerabilities, such as cross-site scripting, injection flaws and buffer overflows, and logical vulnerabilities, which manipulate the logic of the application.
A typical registration form has about 30 unique elements, and checking all of them against more than 70 XSS techniques would require more than 2,000 tests.
No. The paper states that automated tools were never intended to, and should never entirely replace, the manual penetration test, and that the best coverage comes from the right mix of both.
Only a manual tester, because automated scanners cannot understand the business logic behind the application's workflow.